Home › Research › Getting a diagnosis
The effect of different diagnostic criteria on the prevalence of dementia
Erkinjuntti T, Ostbye T, Steenhuis R, Hachinski V.. The New England journal of medicine, 1997-12-01
Topic: Risk, prevention and care in population studies
Plain-language summary
Background There are several widely used sets of criteria for the diagnosis of dementia, but little is known about their degree of agreement and their effects on estimates of the prevalence of dementia. Methods We examined 1879 men and women 65 years of age or older who were enrolled in the Canadian Study of Health and Aging and calculated the proportion given a diagnosis of dementia according to six commonly used classification systems: the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), third edition (DSM-III), the third edition, revised of the DSM (DSM-III-R), the fourth edition of the DSM (DSM-IV), the World Health Organization's International Classification of Diseases (ICD), 9th revision (ICD-9) and 10th revision (ICD-10), and the Cambridge Examination for Mental Disorders of the Elderly (CAMDEX). The degree of concordance among classification schemes and the importance of various factors in determining diagnostic agreement or disagreement were examined. Results The proportion of subjects with dementia varied from 3.1 percent when we used the criteria of the ICD-10 to 29.1 percent when the DSM-III criteria were used. The six classification systems identified different groups of subjects as having dementia; only 20 subjects were given a diagnosis of dementia according to all six systems. The classifications based on the various systems differed little according to the patients' age, sex, educational level, or status with respect to institutionalization. The factors that most often caused disagreement in diagnosis between DSM-III and ICD-10 were long-term memory, executive function, social activities, and duration of symptoms. Conclusions The commonly used criteria for diagnosis can differ by a factor of 10 in the number of subjects classified as having dementia. Such disagreement has serious implications for research and treatment, as well as for the right of many older persons to drive, make a will, and handle financial affairs.
What this study adds
Evidence grade: Low
The record lists 20 participants. The authors say a roughly tenfold difference matters for research, treatment and older people's rights to drive, make a will and manage money. The study does not say which definition is correct.
Taken from this record’s own fields, not from reading the paper. The grade is assigned from the abstract’s wording; what that means.
Cite this study APA, Vancouver, BibTeX · download .bib or .ris
APA 7th
Erkinjuntti, T., Ostbye, T., Steenhuis, R., & Hachinski, V. (1997). The effect of different diagnostic criteria on the prevalence of dementia. The New England journal of medicine. https://doi.org/10.1056/nejm199712043372306
Vancouver
Erkinjuntti T, Ostbye T, Steenhuis R, Hachinski V. The effect of different diagnostic criteria on the prevalence of dementia. The New England journal of medicine. 1997. doi:10.1056/nejm199712043372306. PMID: 9385127.
BibTeX
@article{erkinjuntti1997-9385127,
author = {Erkinjuntti, T. and Ostbye, T. and Steenhuis, R. and Hachinski, V.},
title = {{The effect of different diagnostic criteria on the prevalence of dementia}},
journal = {The New England journal of medicine},
year = {1997},
doi = {10.1056/nejm199712043372306},
pmid = {9385127},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1056/nejm199712043372306}
}
Built from the record alzhub holds for this paper, not looked up. Volume, issue and page numbers are not held in the record. Check the citation against the original before you use it.
Key findings
- Results The proportion of subjects with dementia varied from 3.1 percent when we used the criteria of the ICD-10 to 29.1 percent when the DSM-III criteria were used.
Why it matters
When researchers applied six common diagnostic rulebooks (three DSM editions, two ICD editions and CAMDEX) to the same 1,879 people aged 65 and older in the Canadian Study of Health and Aging, the share labelled as having dementia ranged from 3.1% (ICD-10) to 29.1% (DSM-III), and only 20 people met all six definitions. The authors say a roughly tenfold difference matters for research, treatment and older people's rights to drive, make a will and manage money. The study does not say which definition is correct.
New to this subject? Start with our plain-English guide: Getting a diagnosis →
Study details
- Participants20
- Evidence strengthLow
How this study scored 56/100
Published in a top-tier journal. Scored zero for study design, effect reported and randomized / blinded because the record does not state it.
| Component | Points | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Journal tier | 10 / 10 | Tier 1 — top-tier general journal (The New England journal of medicine) |
| Journal's citation record | 4 / 4 | New England Journal of Medicine: journal h-index 1,505 (OpenAlex, 2026-10-29) |
| Study design | 0 / 12 | No study design recorded — scores zero, not guessed (not stated in the record — scored 0) |
| Strength of evidence | 1 / 5 | Rated “low” in our summary |
| Peer-review validation | 10 / 10 | Peer-reviewed. Published as an article in a named peer-reviewed journal. |
| How recent | 1 / 5 | 1997 — older than 20 years, still counted |
| Sample size | 1 / 4 | 20 participants |
| Effect reported | 0 / 3 | No effect size reported — scores zero (not stated in the record — scored 0) |
| Studied in people | 3 / 3 | Studied in people (participant count stated) |
| Randomized / blinded | 0 / 2 | No randomization or blinding stated — scores zero (not stated in the record — scored 0) |
| Times cited | 6 / 7 | Cited 452 times (OpenAlex, 2026-10-10) |
| Citations per year | 3 / 5 | 14.6 citations a year over 31 year(s) since 1997 |
| Impact for its field and year | 4 / 6 | Cited 14.8× the average for papers of its field and year (OpenAlex FWCI) |
| Cited by studies here | 4 / 6 | Cited by 39 other studies in this library |
| Still being cited | 2 / 4 | Cited 19 times in 2024–2026 (2026 still in progress; OpenAlex) |
| Senior author's track record | 4 / 4 | Last-listed author Vladimir Hachinski: h-index 102 (OpenAlex, whole career) |
| Institution's track record | 1 / 3 | University of Helsinki: institution h-index 1,201 (OpenAlex) |
| Multicenter collaboration | 0 / 3 | OpenAlex lists 1 institution(s) in 1 country — scores zero (affiliation lists can be incomplete) |
| Indexed in PubMed | 2 / 2 | Indexed in PubMed (PMID 9385127) |
| Free to read | 0 / 2 | Behind a paywall — scores zero |
| Total | 56 / 100 | — |
What each of these 20 components measures, and what this score is not →
Read the original
- DOI: 10.1056/nejm199712043372306
- PubMed: 9385127
- Original source →
- Free full text: New England Journal of Medicine →
Full text: free to read — OpenAlex lists this copy as free to read: the link above (checked 6 Feb 1020).
Related
Studies in the library that share something with this one. The line above each title says what.
Studies this one cites
Referenced by this study and also in the alzhub library, so you can read them here.
Later studies that cite this one
39 studies in the alzhub library list this one in their references. Showing the 8 highest-scoring.
Related studies in Getting a diagnosis from nearby years
Also tagged “prevalence”
1,225 studies in the library carry the topic tag “prevalence”; these are this study's neighbours in a fixed, alphabetical-by-hash tour of them, not the closest in content. All 1,225 tagged studies.