Home › Research › What the research found › Every row
Every row of the evidence table
One row per finding: what was tested, which way the result went, and how the study was built. The answer by area, and where the studies disagree, are on the main page.
Every row
Filter
Showing 14 of 382 rows. One row per study per exposure: a study that tested two different things appears twice, once for each.
Scroll the table sideways to see every column.
| Exposure | Question | Direction | Outcome measured | Design | People | Effect size, as the source reported it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carer psychosocial / skills intervention Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyA pilot designed to test feasibility; 68 carers and a 2-week outcome. |
Pre-death grief at 2 weeks | randomised trial | 68 | Pre-death grief Cohen d = -0.38 (mean change -3.29, SD 8.64, p=0.03) at 2 weeks |
JAMA Network Open
2026 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 42018322 |
| Carer psychosocial / skills intervention Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyAt the 1-month comparison the automated self-guided programme reduced depression and burden and increased positive gains versus waitlist; anxiety did not differ. Group differences mostly disappeared once controls received the programme. |
Caregiver depression (PHQ-9) at 1 month versus waitlist (primary); anxiety, burden and positive gains | randomised trial | 274 | At 1-month follow-up, coinciding with exclusive access to PDC30, intervention caregivers showed significant improvements in depression (d = -0.37), burden (d = -0.34), and positive gains (d = 0.42) |
The American journal of geriatric psychiatry : official journal of the American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry
2026 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 41644333 |
| Carer psychosocial / skills intervention Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyA factorial trial of components: the mindfulness component carried the benefit and amplified the others. |
Carer depressive symptoms (PHQ-9) at 12 months | randomised trial | 250 | Mindfulness component: PHQ-9 depressive symptoms β = -2.13 (95% CI -2.85 to -1.38) at 12 months |
JAMA Network Open
2025 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 40094667 |
| Carer psychosocial / skills intervention Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyDirection is for NIDUS-Family: an 89% probability of cost-effectiveness from a health and social care perspective (87% societal) and £8,934 (37%) lower average costs, though the cost difference's confidence interval includes zero. |
Probability of cost-effectiveness at £20,000-30,000 per QALY and 12-month costs versus goal setting and routine care | randomised trial | 302 | At both a £20 000 and £30 000 decision threshold, there was an 89% probability that NIDUS-Family was cost-effective compared with usual care from a health and social care perspective, and an 87% probability from a societal perspective. Intervention participants accrued on average £8934 (37%) less in costs than control participants (95% CI -£59 460 to £41 592) |
The Lancet Healthy Longevity
2025 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 39978389 |
| Carer psychosocial / skills intervention Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyThe outcome is how prepared carers felt to decide about firearm access, not whether any injury was avoided. |
Preparation for Decision Making score | randomised trial | 500 | Preparation for Decision Making score +4.80 points (95% CI 0.53 to 9.07) vs control |
Annals of Internal Medicine
2024 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 39531391 |
| Carer psychosocial / skills intervention Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyBenefit in Hispanic and White caregivers and in Black spousal caregivers; not in Black non-spousal caregivers. |
Caregiver quality of life and depression at 6 months | randomised trial | 642 | Depression: 12.6% (intervention) vs. 22.7% (control) at 6 months |
Annals of Internal Medicine
2006 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 17116917 |
| Carer psychosocial / skills intervention Care, carers and services | Treatment | Benefit | Time to nursing home placement | randomised trial | 406 | HR 0.717 for nursing home placement; median time to placement 557 days longer (model-predicted) in the intervention group |
Neurology
2006 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 17101889 |
| Dementia care management / navigation Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyThe community health worker programme achieved verified linkage to medical care in 16.7% of dyads versus none in the control arm. Caregiver outcomes were largely unchanged, with self-efficacy favouring control. |
Clinic-verified linkage to medical services at 6 months (primary); caregiver psychosocial outcomes | randomised trial | 287 | PLAN increased linkage to medical services versus control (16.7% vs 0%, chi-squared [df = 1] = 24.05, p < 0.001). Caregiver outcomes were largely unchanged, with self-efficacy favoring control |
Alzheimer's & dementia : the journal of the Alzheimer's Association
2026 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 42233272 |
| Dementia care management / navigation Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyDirection is for the extended nursing role intervention: 74% fewer unmet needs and higher quality of life at six months, with a small QALY gain at about 1,425 EUR added cost; no effect on caregiver burden. |
Unmet needs, quality of life, caregiver burden and cost per QALY at six months (advanced dementia care management by nurses in extended roles) | randomised trial | 417 | PlwD receiving the intervention had 74% lower unmet needs (0.26, CI95%: 0.17 to 0.40, p < 0.001) and higher quality of life (0.04, CI95%: 0.01 to 0.07, p = 0.017) than controls. There was a gain in quality-adjusted life years (0.01, CI95%: -0.001 to 0.018) at slightly higher costs (1,425 EUR, CI95%: 638 to 2,211) |
Alzheimer's & Dementia
2025 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 41143334 |
| Dementia care management / navigation Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyDirection is for collaborative dementia care management: fewer neuropsychiatric symptoms, lower caregiver burden, better mental health and 0.137 QALYs gained at no significant added cost (3186€ per QALY) over 36 months; no difference in antidementia drug use, overall quality of life or inappropriate medication. |
Neuropsychiatric symptoms, caregiver burden, quality of life and cost per QALY at 36 months after 6 months of collaborative dementia care management | randomised trial | 428 | Participants receiving CDCM showed significantly fewer behavioral and psychological symptoms (adjusted mean difference [AMD] in NPI score, -10.26 [95% CI, -16.95 to -3.58]; P = .003; Cohen d, -0.78 [95% CI, -1.09 to -0.46]) ... and lower caregiver burden (AMD in BIZA-D score, -0.59 [95% CI, -0.81 to -0.37]; P < .001; Cohen d, -0.71 [95% CI, -1.03 to -0.40]) ... The CDCM group gained QALYs (0.137 [95% CI, 0.000 to 0.274]; P = .049; Cohen d, 0.20 [95% CI, -0.09 to 0.40]) but had no significant increase in costs (437€ [-5438€ to 6313€] [US $476 (95% CI, -$5927 to $6881)]; P = .87; Cohen d, 0.07 [95% CI, -0.14 to 0.28]), resulting in a cost-effectiveness ratio of 3186€ (US $3472) per QALY |
JAMA Network Open
2024 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 38967926 |
| Dementia screening / case finding Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyThe outcome is how many diagnoses were made, not whether anyone was better off. The passive digital marker alone did not raise detection (AOR 0.84, 95% CI 0.63-1.11). |
New dementia diagnosis within 12 months | randomised trial | 5,325 | Adjusted OR for new dementia diagnosis 1.31 (95% CI 1.05-1.64) with QDRS plus passive digital marker vs usual care |
JAMA Network Open
2025 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 41212562 |
| Safety / firearm decision aid Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyThe outcome is how prepared carers felt to decide about firearm access, not whether any injury was avoided. |
Preparation for Decision Making score | randomised trial | 500 | Preparation for Decision Making score +4.80 points (95% CI 0.53 to 9.07) vs control |
Annals of Internal Medicine
2024 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 39531391 |
| Sleep intervention for carers/dyads Care, carers and services | Treatment |
Benefit
whyDirection is for DREAMS START against treatment as usual: a 78% probability of being cost-effective at £20,000 per QALY, with cost and QALY differences individually non-significant. The clinical sleep result is in the table under its own row. |
Cost per QALY gained (within-trial cost-utility) | randomised trial | 377 | The mean incremental difference in QALYs per person with dementia was 0·016 more (95% CI 0·000 to 0·033) for the intervention group than for the TAU group, indicating no significant difference in quality of life. At a £20 000 per QALY gained decision threshold, there was a 78% probability that DREAMS START is cost-effective, compared with TAU |
The Lancet Healthy Longevity
2025 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 40412418 |
| Sleep intervention for carers/dyads Care, carers and services | Treatment | Benefit | Sleep Disorders Inventory at 8 months | randomised trial | 377 | Adjusted mean difference in Sleep Disorders Inventory at 8 months: -4.70 (95% CI -7.65 to -1.74) |
The Lancet Healthy Longevity
2024 ✓ Peer-reviewed PMID 39366393 |